Friday, December 12, 2008

The mask of humankind-journal entries




Reader-Response Criticism (1960s-present)

“Lights, camera, Action” are the typical lines of a director. The reader response theorists believe that when readers read a book they direct their own meaning and importance like a director. A director tries to take a plot, and live it through his or her vision choosing particular lighting, perspective, costume, makeup, and scenery. The director takes a couple of bland plot lines, and makes it his or her own. Similarly, when people read texts, they become the directors, and automatically envision the characters, determine the costumes, the exact lighting and scenery. Reader response theorists believe that they way the production is directed is determined by the “readers age, cultural background, personal life experience, beliefs, and historical vantage”(Reader Response Criticism). Reader response was prompted by Stanley Fish in response to Formalism. Formalism sought to treat the text as objective, and confined the meanings, and interpretations on what the text was saying. The basis of formalism is treating “each work as its own distinct piece, free from its environment, era, and even author…”Formalists assume that the keys to understanding the text exist within ‘”the text itself”’ (Formalism). People like Stanley Fish questioned this, and “believed that a text does not exist without the reader. It is rather like a logic question of whether a tree falling in a forest makes a sound if no one is to hear it. A text sitting on a shelf does nothing. It does not come alive until reader and text are joined (What is). Reader Response theorists emphasize “ that the role of the reader cannot be omitted from the understanding of literature and that readers do not passively consume the meaning presented to them by an objective literary text; rather they actively make the meaning they find in literature”(Reader Response criticism). Some reader response theorist such as “D. Hirsch” believe that it is not valid to read the text with the authors lens because “we cannot know for sure what an author intended in the creation of the work”(Reader Response Criticism). Other reader response theorists believe such as Stanley Fish believe that there is not a “central or authorized reading of a text; there are only readings. The idea of containing interpretation though an appeal to authorized intention is a chimera (Reader Response Criticism). Reader Response theorists believe that people “turn themselves into detectives readers of clues. Readers simultaneously comb the sentences carefully for information and allow their imaginations free play in conjuring up possibilities (R.R.C) Thus, the reader response theory is an approach to studying literature that can take on any lens. This theory seeks to explore the different views, impressions, and messages that readers get from a particular novel.

Thus, with this reader response lens I am going to seek to understand Mary Shelly’s novel Frankenstein. The reader response is similar to a rainbow; a rainbow has an infinite amount of different shades of color. Similarly, the reader response theory can have an infinite amount of lenses that readers could have. However, I am going to focus my attention on the way psychoanalytic theorist would see the text and they way a feminist would. Psychoanalysts believe is that “a work of literature is the external expression of the author’s unconscious mind (psychoanalytic criticism).” The feminist criticism “is concerned with the ways in which literature (and other cultural productions) reinforce or undermine the economic, social, and psychological oppression of women” (Tyson). This essay will be concerned with these two primarily, but other lenses are also adopted.

Work Citied Page

Formalism (1930's to present). 09 Dec 2008. Owl.english.purdue.edu. 12 Dec 2008 .

"Reader Response Criticism." 9 Dec 2008. Calvertonschool.org. 12 Dec 2008 .

PSYCHOANALYTIC CRITICISM. 12 Dec 2008. Web.olivet.edu. 12 Dec 2008 .

"What is Reader Response Criticism?." WiseGeek. 12 Dec 2008. Wisegeek. 12 Dec 2008



Are we all hiding under a mask?
Journal Entries

Robert Walton

1) “My father loved Beaufort with the truest friendship and was deeply grieved by his retreat in these unfortunate circumstances?. He bitterly deplored the false pride which led his friend ship and was deeply grieved by his retreat in these unfortunate circumstances” … Beaufort had taken effectual measures to conceal himself and it was ten months before my father discovered his adobe.. His grief only became more deep and rankling when he had leisure for reflection”(21).

In the quote we see that Beaufort out of his false pride becomes the puppet of his own creation. He does not accept circumstances. He does not think of the new. He allows himself to be stifled with time, which Shelly plans out for a reason. She shows that men are not as strong as one would like to think. They need someone to show that they are not weak-a women. However, when you take out the support, what is it that is left…

2) “Caroline Beaufort possessed a mind of an uncommon mold, and her courage rose to support her in her adversity. She procured plain work; she plaited straw; and by various means contrived to earn a pittance scarcely sufficient to support”(21)

Caroline Beaufort is depicted as valiant. She is superior to her father, to a male, because she does fight circumstances. Her father is willing to starve and die, but not work in something that he considers degrading. His daughter on the other hand is wiser and is willing to change as circumstances change. This quote shows the positive attribute of women.

3) Her father died in her arms leaving her an orphan and beggar. The last below came who committed herself to his care; and after the interment of his friend he conducted her to Geneva and placed her under the protection of a relationship. Two years after this event Caroline became his wife” ( 21)

As feminists would argue, this side of women shows the submissive and the dependent part of a women. I think that it largely had to do with society; society was not willing to accept independent young women. This shows that even the strongest women end up following society’s norms.

4) Their benevolent disposition often made them enter the cottages of the poor. This, to my mother, was more than a duty; it was a necessity, a passion-remembering what she had suffered and how she had been relieved…(22).

We again see the women depicted as dedicated and caring. Had she been a male, then she would have never wanted to go back. Men in the novel tend to not go back to the past; they did not want to relive the moments. Here, we have a women that is willing to relieve the past and grow from her experiences”(22)

5) “And when, on the morrow, she presented Elizabeth to me as her promised gift with childish seriousness, interpreted her words literally and looked upon Elizabeth as mine-mine to protect, love, and cherish. All praises bestowed on her I received as made to a possession of my own…since till death she was to be mine only :”(23)

We can see in this quote that women are suppressed, and that their future is determined at the time of birth. Women do not have any real support. I think that Shelly puts Elizabeth in the novel as a support for Victor, because if he did not have this support, then things would have fallen apart way earlier.

6) How can I describe my emotions at this catastrophe, or how delineate the wretch whom with such infinite pains and care i endeavored to form? his limbs were in proportion, and I had selected his features as beautiful. Beautiful! Great god! his yellow skin scarcely covered the work of muscles and arties beneath; his hair was lustrous black, and flowing; his teeth of a pearly whiteness; but these luxuriance’s only formed a more horrid contrast with his watery eyes, that seemed almost of the same color as the dun white sockets in which they were set, his shriveled complexion and straight black lips” (44-45)

Victor Frankenstein tries to become a god and thus his creation is created so people can adore him. Victor Frankenstein wanted to have a child, so people could know him from an accomplishing a feat… a task that only god could perform. He was drawn by this idea, and thus created his creature. He became so blinded that he did not even realize what he had created looked monstrous. The moment he realized this, he deserted his child.

7) I had no fear, therefore, that any circumstantial evidence could be put forward strong enough to convict her. My tale was not one to announce publicly; its astounding horror would be looked upon as madness by the vulgar. Did anyone indeed exist, the creator, who would believe, unless his senses convinced him, in the existence of the living moment of presumption and rash ignorance which I had let lose upon he world” (64).

This again shows the flaws of a man. A female embraces her creation, loves it, and the male, once discovering that his creation is flawed, runs away from it. Victor is more concerned about his image in society, then trying to protect Justine from being convicted of a crime that she did not do. Not only is not willing to confess of his crime, but is not willing to stop another from happening.



8) “During all that period she appeared to me the most amiable and benevolent of human creatures. She nursed Madam Frankenstein, my aunt, in her last illness, with the greatest affection and care and afterward attended her own mother during a tedious illness, in a manner that excited the admiration of all who knew her, after which she again lived n my uncle’s house, where she was beloved by all the family. She was warmly attached to the child who is now dead and acted towards him” (69)

The proof that they have against Justine is arbitrary. The males, which are supposed to be the individuals that are strong, appear weak. None of the males are willing to stand up, and it is the female that is willing to stand up. This shows that a woman is so committed to something that she can give her life as Justine is going to do. Is this the most wise thing to do? However, I think that Justine knows that the desire to find a scapegoat is engraved in the minds of people, and despite her innocence, she is charged of a crime she did not do. I think that the villagers also know that, but are able to bring peace to their mind by the thought of someone being punished for disorder.

9) She attended her sickbed; her watchful attention triumphed over the malignity of the distemper-Elizabeth was save, but the consequences of this imprudence were fatal to her preserver. On the third day my mother sickened; her fever was accompanied by the most alarming symptoms, and the looks of her medical attendant prognosticated the worst event. On her deathbed the fortitude and benignity of this best women did not desert her “ (31)

This again shows that women will go though situations till the every end. They do not just desert their child, even when these women are on the verge of death. Victor Frankenstein; however, had left his childhood alone since its birth,

10) “Everywhere I see bliss, from which I alone am irrevocably excluded. I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend. Make me happy, and I again shall be virtuous” (83).

This quote shows that loneliness can drive people to take the wrong actions. A person forgets about society. They are so shattered that anything or any possibility that suggests that this deprivation can be soothed is considered. This also gives the monster a very human feel; before the person does not know the motive of the monster. A person thinks that the monster is some type of evil person, but now we can delve into the matter. It also explores the question if whether or not man is instantly like that when he does not have any companions-what is it that is left?

11) “ You, my creator, abhor me; what hope can I gather from your fellow creatures, who owe me nothing They spurn and hate me. The desert mountains and dreary glaciers are my refuge. I have wondered here many days; the caves of ice, which I do not fear are a dwelling to me, and the only one which man does not grudge” (85)

The question then arises, when something like Frankenstein appears.. What is it that humans are afraid of? Why do not people care that he is in the caves of ice. I think that they do not care, because the cave is a place where a person is lonely, and humans do not like to be lonely. Thus. It also gives evidence to what Victor’s Frankenstein was trying to say. He became the way he was, because people wanted him to act according to a certain criteria.

12) If the multitude knew of my existence, they would do as you do and arm themselves for my destruction. Shall I then not hate them who abhor me? I will keep my terms with my enemies. I am miserable and they shall share my wretchedness (84)

Frankenstein feels so lonely that he wants people to suffer as much as he is. I do not think of him as monstrous, but very human lie. If he did not find offense to people banishing him, and abhorring, I would say that he would be either god like or unable to express emotions. I think this represents Shelly, she is so suppressed in her life, that it does not matter anymore what people think.

13) “Why do you call to my remembrance,” I rejoined, a “circumstances of which I shudder to reflect, that I have been the miserable origin and author? Cursed by the day, abhorred devil, in which you first say light! Cursed be the hands that formed you! You have made me wretched beyond expression. You have left me no power to consider whither I am just to you or not Be gone! Relieve me from the sight of your detested form”( 84)

Now, the question arises why Victor Frankenstein is truly miserable. Is it because he is not able to achieve the fame that he wanted to… This portrays men as very impulsive, men in general. In the novel, women are overly devoted to their creations, or their children. They are willing to die for them… I think that Mary Shelly also trying to assert that giving birth and creating life can only be possible within the domain of women.

14) “Felix seemed ravished with delight when he saw her, every trait of sorrow vanished from his face, and it instantly expressed a degree of ecstatic joy, of which I could hardly have believed it capable; his eyes sparkled, as his check flushed with pleasure…” (98).

Felix is very depressed in his life. However, when he sees the Arabian girl, his pain vanishes away. I think that the monster learns from this. He then starts desiring a women, because she could also alleviate his pains away.

15) “ You minutely described in these papers every step you took in the progress of your work; this history was mingled in accounts of domestic occurrences”( 110 )

Even though the creation has the formula of a women in his hands… He does not make a women himself; instead, he instructs his creator to make him one.. I think that subconsciously the creation is afraid of being the creator; he does not want to enter the domain, because it might bring him immense pain.

16) “They did not appear rich, but they were contented and happy; their feelings were serene and peaceful, while mine became every day more tumultuous. Increase of knowledge only discovered to me more clearly what a wretched outcast I was. I cherished hope, it is true, but vanished when I beheld my person reflected in water or my shadow in the moonshine, even as that frail image and that inconstant shade”(111).

Knowledge is becoming dangerous for Frankenstein’s creation. He soon starts thinking like a human, and judges himself by his outer appearance-his outer coat. He also learns that the creator he idolizes is not flawless, but filled with flaws. Thus, since he is Frankenstein’s creation, he innately becomes flawed.

17) “This was then the reward of my benevolence. I had saved a human being from destruction and as recompense I now writhed under the miserable pain of a wound which shattered the flesh and bone. The feelings of kindness and gentleness which I had entertained but a few moments before gave place to hellish rage and gnashing of teeth. In flamed by pain, I vowed eternal hatred and vengeance to all mankind. But the agony of my wound overcame me; my pulses paused and I fainted (120)

Frankenstein Creation at first thinks that the way he looks causes people to be scared of him. But now he discoverers that even when he does something pretty, they still judge him impulsively. I think it is toward this part of the novel that the creature discovers that humans are flawed, and that it is not his fault. This kind of shows Shelly’s mother, even when Shelly’s mother tried to get women more involved, a good cause, people still questioned her,, because she was trying to get out of the mob that people become.

18) I am alone and miserable; man will not associate with me; but one as deformed and horrible as myself would not deny herself to me. My companion must be of the same species and have the same defects. This being you must create” (123)

I think that Shelly needed somebody that thought like her… that had her mindset. This she chooses one of her dad’s friends, because he shares similar views, and perspectives. Both for Frankenstein and Shelly the desire of a companion gives new dimension and desire in their life.

19) “It is true, we shall be monsters, cut off from all the world; but on the account we shall be more attached to one another. Our lives will not be happy, but they ill be harmless and free from the misery I feel” (125)

This shows that Frankenstein is not monstrous. It shows his desire to conform into society. He does not desire to make people change his views about him…but seeks to do what people want him to do, and that is to be perished from their life. He is willing to do that, but he just needs a companion… a person to talk to,

20) “ I shall die, and what I now feel be no longer felt. Soon those burning memories will be extent. I shall ascend my funeral pile triumphantly and exalt in the torturing flames. The light of that conflagration will fade away; my ashes will be swept into the sea by the winds. My spirit will sleep in peace or if it thinks, it will surely think thus, Farewell.

This quote puts death as the ultimate solution of all the problems. But by death what is anybody trying to achieve… I think that by death a person achieves freedom from their pain… but then the question is what the source of this problem…Is a person destined to suffer but from who, from himself, or is it from other’s. Does not the desire to be loved come from the existence of two people?